With recent rumours sparking about the new live action version of our beloved Rapunzel being played by an Indian actress, I have seen and heard a multitude of opinions. While I am all for inclusivity, ideas like this always strike a nerve in me.

Let’s state the facts first. Rapunzel was originally a German fairy tale, first published by the Brothers Grimm in 1812. Notoriously known for her long, luscious, golden hair, she is the hallmark for so many people’s childhoods. Recently, Avantika Vandanapu was rumoured to be playing the role of Rapunzel in the live action movie (stated by NBC and USA Today); however, this was never confirmed. She was previously featured in the new Mean Girls movie. There has been severe backlash based on this rumour, with one side arguing that it would be lovely to have an Indian as Rapunzel. On the other hand, there have also been extreme comments, discussing how Rapunzel’s story would be ruined by this actress, and how it is unfair that a German folk story is being told from an Indian perspective.

I have been asked numerous times if I believe that what is being done is appropriate. There is almost a fear in people when they ask me this, as they assume that I will always side with the idea that having the Indian actress is the best option, when, in fact, it is quite the opposite. Growing up, I always envisioned Rapunzel as a princess with beautiful golden hair, and honestly, the idea of casting her asn an Indian irked me. There are two main reasons for this:

I don’t believe that diversity should overshadow cherished childhood memories.
For many of us, Rapunzel isn’t just a story; she represents the magic of childhood—her long, flowing golden hair symbolising dreams, freedom, and adventure. It can change a sense of nostalgia for the original tale, steeped in its German roots. While inclusivity in casting is essential for reflecting the diverse world we live in, it’s crucial to consider how such changes might affect the emotional connection many of us have to these beloved characters. I believe that the essence of Rapunzel will be lost if this switch is made.

Why not create an Indian Princess instead?
The Indian mythology that exists in the world is so rich, deep-rooted and creative, it seems like the perfect opportunity to be diverse. Instead of filmmakers replacing more established characters with ‘diverse’ ones, they should capitalise on the history of these cultures and make new cinematic creations with them. It takes away from the core idea of being diverse if we are just throwing in people from minority groups into movies, as it just makes it seem forced.